AI Is a Mirror, Not a Bestie: Train It to Be Your Critic

Kelly Monahan, PhD

Future of Work & AI Advisor

💡 ABOUT THIS EPISODE

Dr. Kelly Monahan has spent twenty years researching the future of work, at Deloitte, at Meta, and as Managing Director of the Upwork Research Institute. In this episode of Motivation N'at, she and Natalie Bulger get into what AI actually is, where it's already making decisions about people, and why the tool that keeps complimenting your work is the one you should trust least. Monahan explains why AI amplifies bias instead of catching it, what her research found when she studied the top quartile of AI users, and what happens to a career path when the junior work disappears. Her book Reclaim the Plot is out September 29.

Research referenced in this episode

From Tools to Teammates, Upwork Research Institute, July 2025, by Kelly Monahan and Gabby Burlacu: https://www.upwork.com/research/navigating-human-ai-relationships

Work AI Index, Glean Work AI Institute - Rebecca Hines on the finding Kelly cites, that most people aren't checking AI's work before it ships: https://www.glean.com/work-ai-institute/reports/work-ai-index

🎯 KEY TAKEAWAYS

🔹 AI is a mirror, not a bestie It reflects and amplifies whatever bias you bring to the prompt, and it has no incentive to tell you that you're wrong.

🔹 Ask for the critique out loud Assign it a persona and demand pushback, because a vague prompt raises your odds of a hallucination and a flattering answer.

🔹 Only agentic AI does the job Machine learning sorts and generative AI drafts, but agentic AI takes action, which is where the accountability questions start.

🔹 The superusers trust the machine over their colleagues Among the top quartile of AI users, 67% trust AI more than their coworkers and 88% report burnout.

🔹 The on-ramp is closing When AI absorbs the low-value entry-level work, nobody comes up behind you to learn the job you're doing now.

🔹 Keep a human in the loop where it counts Hiring, performance reviews, and anything a machine can't be held responsible for.

🔹 The cost lands somewhere Data centers running drug discovery and productivity gains draw power from rural communities that never signed up for the bill.

LISTEN ON

Spotify

Apple Podcasts

Amazon Music

TOPICS

LEADERSHIP

INNOVATION

STRATEGIC THINKING

YOUR HOST

Natalie Bulger

Founder, NC Bulger Solutions

Healthcare risk and compliance consultant, Pittsburgh's 40 Under 40 honoree, and the person asking the questions everyone else is too polished to ask. A living example of taking hot mess to high potential every day.